The Best

Thin Mints - S+ if frozen. They disappear faster than they should.

Samoas - the only unique GS cookie

Good

Do-Si-Dos - good PB taste and crunch

Decent

Tagalongs - waxy and fake tasting chocolate, but PB + chocolate + crunch combo

Meh

Lemon-Ups - too sweet, soft would be better than crunch in the lineup IMO

Trefoils - too sweet, too much fake vanilla flavor. not shortbread at all, basically nilla wafers

Toffee-Tastic - not an effective toffee delivery system

Avoid

Girl Scout S'mores - disgusting fake chocolate and vanilla flavor, if this tastes like a smore to you then you might have COVID.

Note: the only ones really worth buying are thin mints and samoas. Everything is is done better elsewhere